Old Florida Fish House

Family-owned since 2005, Old Florida Fish House sits on the edge of Eastern Lake — one of the coast’s rare dune lakes — serving classic Old Florida seafood alongside an unexpected sushi program. The screened porch and lakeside deck fill nightly with live music, and the dueling-piano nights are a local legend. It’s a full evening: gelato shop and gift store at the entrance, sax players on the deck, and grouper on the plate.